by Danube Noel-Johnson Introduction As contemporary analyses of the status of religion in modern nation-states suggest, secularism has led to the relegation of religious practices, belief, and values to the private sphere. The private—particularity, subjectivity, irrationality, religion, domesticity, the mystic—is distinguished from what is considered the public sphere, which is characterized by modern, liberal principles—universality, […]
Category: Opinions
Opinion pieces do not reflect the views of Understanding Theology itself. They are included to provide readers with an understanding of the different debates and disagreements that are a part of Theology.
What Can We Learn From ISIS?
by Theo Poward The story of ISIS since around 2014 has been one of terrifying spread and painful recovery. It was and is a plague. But unlike medical plagues, it prompts violence in its carriers, violence that destroys the societies that they belong to. The symptoms were obvious, brutish, and well documented. But, the cause […]
The Medieval Cult of Saints: Vulgar Compromises or Divine Experiments?
by Michael S. Hahn The cult of saints was one of the most prominent and significant forms of worship and devotion in the late-antique and medieval periods. However, in the last forty years, there has been a shift in scholarly opinion as to how this movement began and developed, and its place in late-antique society. […]
An Essay on Personal Religious Conviction and Political Duty
by Stephanie Redfern Jones A few nights ago, I watched an episode of the popular BBC television quiz programme, Mastermind, and although it featured notable celebrities, I was surprised to see Tim Farron. The ex-Liberal Democrat party leader resigned in June 2017 over what he said was clash between his personal Christian convictions and political […]
Does it Matter Where our Christmas Traditions Came From? – Towards a Positive Genealogy of Christmas.
by Chris Lynch Amidst the rituals and tropes associated with celebrating Christmas, thinkers and commentators occasionally intervene to highlight how Christmas as practised in 2017 Britain is in some important respects culturally specific, politically problematic, and not as straightforwardly wrapped up with ‘authentic’ Christianity as commonly assumed. Motivating these interventions seems to be the thought […]
Colorado Cake: Is ‘Religion’ driving Legal Discrimination? Not so fast
by Theo Poward You may be vaguely familiar with the Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission case which is currently pending before the US Supreme Court. In July 2012, same-sex couple Charlie Craig and David Mullins from Colorado visited Masterpiece Cakeshop in Denver to order a custom wedding cake for a celebration of their marriage. Masterpiece’s owner […]
A Pyrrhic Victory of the Politics of Tolerance?
by Frederik Seidelin On Tuesday, people in Denmark went to the polls to elect local councillors for the next four years. The campaigning period saw right-wing populists opposing building permits for mosques, opposing Muslim women wearing headscarves in the health sector, and similar religion-related value politics that we have, sadly, come to expect in Western […]
Half a Millennium of Modernity and Exceptionalism?
By Frederik Seidelin Last week, 31 October marked the fifth centenary of Martin Luther sending his Ninety-five Theses to the Archbishop of Mainz. This particular action (and his alleged nailing of his theses to the church door in Wittenberg) is now seen as the beginning of the reformations of the Catholic church that swept across […]